CBI: Different strokes for different folks

by Abraham Thomas

The CBI’s handling of cases involving Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Mayawati, Samajwadi Party chief Mulayam Singh Yadav and former Bihar CM Lalu Prasad has exposed the varied yardsticks adopted by the probe agency in dealing with these political heavyweights.To start with, all three leaders faced Disproportion Asset cases in which the assessment of the Income Tax department was key to their prosecution. While in case of Lalu and Mulayam, the CBI turned a blind eye to I-T department’s relief to them, in case of Mayawati, the agency claimed that the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal’s (ITAT) clean chit to her was based on “assumptions” and that it had sufficient evidence to prosecute the BSP chief.

Interestingly, Mayawati had raised the ITAT decisions of April 5 and April 19 this year to allege double standards against the Centre, claiming the CBI had let them (Mulayam Singh and Lalu Prasad) off on the basis of Income Tax department’s clean chit.

Followings details will serve to highlight the pick-and-choose approach of the country’s premier investigating agency.

Mayawati (BSP chief)

Mayawati seems to have run into a rough patch with the Centre lately. This explains the latest demand by the CBI, investigating charges of disproportionate assets against her, to prosecute her despite the Income Tax Tribunal giving a ruling in her favour by dismissing her unaccounted wealth as merely “gifts”.

The latest move by Mayawati to downsize Congress in Uttar Pradesh is evident from her recent decision to rename Amethi and remove chunks of population out of Amethi and Rae Bareli districts in the UP to carve out a new district named after Dalit icon Chhatrapati Sahuji Maharaj.

But the very same CBI now wanting to prosecute Mayawati, six years ago desired to file a closure report against her. Then, it was the valuable intervention of the apex court that chided the agency for relying on opinion rendered by law officers, forcing the CBI to draw a chargesheet against her.

It was on September 18, 2003, that the Supreme Court handed CBI the probe into Mayawati's assets in relation to the Taj Heritage Corridor project where the State Government had illegally diverted Rs 17 crore without obtaining mandatory clearances. Based on preliminary probe into the case, the CBI recommended registration of FIR against Mayawati and her Cabinet colleague Naseemuddin Siddiqui, the then State Environment Minister.

On December 31, 2004, the CBI Director in his status report to the apex court disclosed that the evidence was not sufficient to prosecute Mayawati and that the agency should be given permission to file a closure report in the case. The suggestion was backed by a legal opinion of Attorney General who held, "In absence of any evidence to suggest criminal mens rea on the part of any individual and due to lack of evidence of any pecuniary benefit to any of the officers or any other person, the proper course of action would be to take disciplinary action against the officers for their omission and misconduct."

Mulayam Singh

Samajwadi Party leader Mulayam Singh is awaiting the decision on an application moved by the CBI before the Supreme Court to withdraw prosecution against him in a case of disproportionate assets alleged to be acquired by him and his family.

The application dated November 17, 2008, was moved by the CBI, placing reliance on the opinion given by then Solicitor General Goolam E Vahanvati who recommended withdrawal of prosecution against the SP chief. The law officer suggested that assets possessed by Mulayam and his family must be "segregated" and if accounting of the assets is done considering this fact, the assets of the former UP Chief Minister would come to Rs 2.6 crore.

But the silence of the CBI was most noteworthy. This was the same agency that moved an application in October 2007 seeking permission from the court to further probe the charges against Mulayam and his family. In pressing for the demand, the agency claimed it had "sufficient evidence" gathered from its preliminary investigation conducted on basis of the March 1, 2007 order of the Supreme Court directing a CBI probe into the illegal assets of Mulayam, his children and daughter-in-law.

What changed over the one-year period (October 2007-November 2008) was the changing political relationship between the UPA Government at Centre and the Samajwadi Party. The Left Front, an ally of the UPA Government, had withdrawn support to the Centre in July 2008 over the nuclear deal. With the Samajwadi Party offering its unconditional support to the Centre, the CBI was merely formalising the thaw in relation by negating its own investigation.

But to justify its blow-hot-blow-cold approach, the CBI chose an alibi in the opinion given by Director of Prosecution, SK Sharma. This opinion was merely a stamp of approval to the Solicitor General's opinion and was a desperate attempt by the Government to please its strange but new bedfellow.

Lalu Prasad

In case of Lalu, the Income Tax and CBI joined hands to bail out Lalu Prasad.

First, Income Tax authorities gave clean chit to Lalu on July 2, 2004, despite a clear finding against him that a sum of Rs 70,000 had escaped assessment for the assessment years, 1986-87 and 1996-97.

Then the CBI refused to appeal against the Special CBI Judge (AHD), Patna, order acquitting both Lalu and Rabri. In fact, the CBI opposed the State Government's appeal in the high court and contested it up to the SC.

One of the judges of the three-member SC Bench, who had dissented with the Bench in upholding the Income Tax clean chit to Lalu, had commented: "This court has noticed in number of cases that even an innocuous statement of the (Income Tax) tribunal against the Revenue officers is challenged before the higher courts on the grounds that such observations are aspersions against the officers who have performed their duty and that they need to be expunged….Applying the same yardstick one fails to understand as to why the Revenue has not moved in appeal even when its own higher officers are branded as biased in deciding matters against Lalu and Rabri."

COURTESY: THE PIONEER , AUG 30 /10

Other Related Articles

Ram Nath Kovind is not a Dalit, Dalit is a Spring of Political Consciousness
Tuesday, 20 June 2017
  Saidalavi P.C. The propaganda minister in Nazi Germany, Joseph Goebbels was so sharp in his thinking that we have come to quote his famous aphorism regarding the plausibility of a lie being... Read More...
'The Manu Smriti mafia still haunts us': A speech by a Pakistani Dalit Rights Leader
Thursday, 15 June 2017
  Surendar Valasai Probably the first comprehensive political statement for Dalit rights in Pakistan framed in the vocabulary of Dalitism was given in 2007 by Surendar Valasai, who is now the... Read More...
Babasaheb’s Statue Vandalized: Bengal’s Realm of Caste maliciousness
Wednesday, 14 June 2017
   Pinak Banik On the midnight of 29th May, a marble bust of Babasaheb Ambedkar was found disfigured. This statue was installed 17 years ago inside the Dr. B. R. Ambedkar Sishu Uddyan... Read More...
Oppose the scrapping of financial aid to SC, ST students in TISS
Wednesday, 14 June 2017
    Statement Against the arbitrary note by Registrar (TISS) deciding to discontinue DH and Hostel to eligible GoI-PMS SC/ST students "Lack of education leads to lack of wisdom, which leads... Read More...
An Appeal by Adivasi Dalit Mazdoor Kisan Sangharsh
Tuesday, 13 June 2017
  Adivasi Dalit Mazdoor Kisan Sangharsh Appeal by Adivasi Dalit Mazdoor Kisan Sangharsh Raigarh13 June 2017 Dear friends in Media and Civil Society, Displacement without consent is a crime!... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

The Death of a Historian in Centre for Historical Studies, JNU
Sunday, 19 March 2017
  Jitendra Suna Speech made at the protest by BAPSA on 16th March, 2017 against the Institutional Murder of Muthukrishnan (Rajini Krish) I am Jitendra Suna, and I am from a remote village named... Read More...
I Will Not Exit Your House Without Letting You Know That I am a Dalit
Thursday, 02 March 2017
  Riya Singh Yes, I am assertive. Assertive of my caste identity. It is not a 'fashion statement' trust me, it takes a lot of courage and training of your own self to be this assertive. You... Read More...
On the Anxieties surrounding Dalit Muslim Unity
Friday, 17 February 2017
  Ambedkar Reading Group Delhi University  Recently we saw the coming together of Dalits and Muslims at the ground level, against a common enemy - the Hindu, Brahminical State and Culture -... Read More...
Interview with Prof Vivek Kumar on the Bahujan Movement
Monday, 13 March 2017
  Round Table India In this episode of the Ambedkar Age series, Round Table India talks to Prof Vivek Kumar, Professor, Centre for the Study of Social Systems, School of Social Sciences,... Read More...
Brahmin Feminism sans Brahmin Patriarch
Monday, 06 February 2017
  Kanika S It has almost become common sense that feminism has been shaped exclusively by a class of women that came from Brahmin-Savarna castes in India, to the extent that even trashy... Read More...

Recent Articles in Hindi

पेरियार से हम क्या सीखें?

पेरियार से हम क्या सीखें?

  संजय जोठे  इस देश में भेदभाव और शोषण से भरी परम्पराओं का विरोध करने वाले अनेक विचारक और क्रांतिकारी हुए हैं जिनके बारे में हमें बार-बार पढ़ना और समझना चाहिए. दुर्भाग्य से इस देश के शोषक वर्गों के षड्यंत्र के कारण इन क्रांतिकारियों का जीवन परिचय और समग्र कर्तृत्व छुपाकर रखा जाता है. हमारी अनेकों पीढियां इसी षड्यंत्र में जीती आयीं हैं. किसी देश के उद्भट विचारकों और क्रान्तिकारियों को इस...

Read more

कृष्ण: भारतीय मर्द का एक आम चेहरा...!

कृष्ण: भारतीय मर्द का एक आम चेहरा...!

(कृष्ण की लोक लुभावन छवि का पुनर्पाठ!)मानुषी आखिर ये मिथकीय कहानियां किस तरह की परवरिश और शिक्षा देती हैं, जहां पुरुषों को सारे अधिकार हैं, चाहे वह स्त्री को अपमानित करे या दंडित, उसे स्त्री पलट कर कुछ नहीं कहती। फिर आज हम रोना रोते हैं कि हमारे बच्चे इतने हिंसक और कुंठित क्यों हो रहे हैं। सारा दोष हम इंटरनेट और टेलीविजन को देकर मुक्त होना चाहते हैं। जबकि स्त्री...

Read more

राष्ट्रवाद और देशभक्ति

राष्ट्रवाद और देशभक्ति

संजय जोठे धर्म जो काम शास्त्र लिखकर करता है वही काम राष्ट्र अब फ़िल्में और विडिओ गेम्स बनाकर बनाकर करते हैं. इसी के साथ सुविधाभोगी पीढ़ी को मौत से बचाने के लिए टेक्नालाजी पर भयानक खर्च भी करना पड़ता है ताकि दूर बैठकर ही देशों का सफाया किया जा सके, और यही असल में उस तथाकथित “स्पेस रिसर्च” और “अक्षय ऊर्जा की खोज” की मूल प्रेरणा है, यूं तो सबको...

Read more