If Dalits do not support Arundhati Roy, they are all pro-hindutva?


K. Satyanarayana

[This is a comment on the recent article by Dr. N. Sukumar (Dalit Revolution and Hindutva Counter Revolution in Indian Politics) on Round Table India which questioned the new discourse in the opinion columns of mainstream media on how the Dalit movement has supposedly taken a 'rightward' shift. Thanks Dr Satyanarayana for keeping the debate going!]


Dear Sukumar,

Thank you for this timely reply. You have rightly rejected the mischievous view that Dalits are taking a rightward shift in Indian politics. Just because one is in JNU and in the dept of Political Science, one should not present himself as a self-appointed expert on Dalit politics. Based on some newspaper reports and half-baked truths, Ajay Gudavarthy made a sweeping generalisation about Dalits and their politics in India. He is irresponsible to push Dalits into the Hindutva fold by citing some 3 or 4 Dalit politicians joining BJP and the electoral victory of BJP in some pockets of the country. His article in the Hindu is full of common sense assumptions and half baked truths. See some examples: 

1. Ajay claims "the larger sub castes among the Dalits have mostly converted to Christianity and some to Islam, leaving the smaller sub castes the sole option of moving to the Hindu fold." On what basis is this statement made? He is advising some sub castes to go to BJP? Is conversion (for social and spiritual reasons) the same as joining the Hindutva forces?

2. "This is why Mr. Raj joining the BJP or Ram Vilas Paswan joining the coalition is perceived as part of a pragmatic move necessary for the current Dalit agenda, while Arundhati Roy writing on B.R. Ambedkar is perceived as an illegitimate appropriation and worse, as "poaching" from the outside. Here, strangely, Dalit politics uses the exclusivist Dalit identity and the need to be born a Dalit to speak of caste and Ambedkar."

So those who "perceived" Arundhati Roy's writing as appropriation and those who defend Udit Raj and Paswan are "the same Dalits." What a way to defend Arundhati Roy who is advertised as co-author of Annihilation of Caste by Verso publishers in London! If Dalits do not support your Arundhati, they are all pro-hindutva? Is this the logic?

"The same Dalits" endorse neo-liberal politics. If this is the logic, who is Ajay Gudavarthy representing? Can we say he is speaking for all upper castes in India because of his caste? Or he is the only radical anti-hindutva left and secular intellectual left in the country?

3."Mobility by gaining acceptance looks far more tangible and achievable than the abstract and rather Utopian idea of annihilating caste." Which Dalits are making this argument? All Dalits in the country? Is this your advice to Dalits?

While the BJP is making a concerted attempt to win over Dalit people as part of vote bank politics, any concerned public intellectual would analyse the implications and critique the Hindutva agenda as dangerous. Anand Teltumbde did this in EPW by criticizing the three Dalit Rams for joining BJP.

Ajay represents himself as a secular and left scholar and bemoans the tragic turn of the Dalit community. This stereotype of the Dalits as a caste community (that always acts as a caste group) is a view that helps the upper caste intellectuals to occupy the radical and secular identity and also to hide their caste identity. By this logic, the Brahmins and other upper castes are a diversified community which has both secular and caste minded people but the Dalits are a homogeneous group tied to their caste. It is the secular upper caste intellectual who imposes "the exclusivist Dalit identity" on the Dalits. Ajay's article is the best example of this.

If the space in The Hindu is reserved for some, the site of internet and the websites like the Round Table India are all there for Dalits and others for spreading alternative views.

Thank you Sukumar for your critical analysis.

~ K. Satyanarayana

Associate Professor, EFL University, Hyderabad. 


Other Related Articles

Mahatma Phule's Thoughts on Caste-Patriarchy: A Critical Evaluation
Thursday, 16 November 2017
  Sachin Garud It is a well-known fact that at the time of India's national movement, there was another movement known as the movement of social engineering or social revolution, led by Mahatma... Read More...
Becoming Minority- An Unsettling Inquiry into a ‘Settled’ Concept
Wednesday, 15 November 2017
  Bhakti Deodhar (Book review of Becoming minority: How Discourses and Policies Produce minorities in Europe and India, edited by Jyotirmay Tripathi and Sudarshan Padmanabhan, New Delhi, Sage... Read More...
Speech and the Speaker's Identity
Monday, 13 November 2017
  Tejas Harad In 2016, famous Indian author Chetan Bhagat published a novel called One Indian Girl. This book was criticised by some women because the book's narrator, who is also its... Read More...
Celebrating 7th November as Students' Day
Friday, 10 November 2017
  Rahul Pagare The government of Maharashtra declared 7th of November to be celebrated as Students' Day on the occasion of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar's first day of school entry, back in 1900 AD.... Read More...
Surveillance and Punishment in the Village: Reflections on Imayam’s Pethavan
Thursday, 09 November 2017
  Karthick RM "Hence the major effect of the Panopticon: to induce in the inmate a state of conscious and permanent visibility that assures the automatic functioning of power."-Michel Foucault... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

No Mr. Tharoor, I Don’t Want to Enter Your Kitchen
Saturday, 16 September 2017
Tejaswini Tabhane Shashi Tharoor is an author, politician and former international civil servant who is also a Member of Parliament representing the constituency of Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala. This... Read More...
Gandhi's Caste and Guha's Upper Caste Identity Politics
Tuesday, 13 June 2017
  Nidhin Shobhana In today's editorial page of Indian Express, Ramachandra Guha has written an essay by the title 'Does Gandhi have a Caste?'[1] In the essay, Guha tries really hard to establish... Read More...
A Peep into the Soft Porn Film Industry of Keralam
Friday, 30 June 2017
  Anilkumar PV The setting of the last millennium saw the rise of a new star in the horizon of Malayalam film industry: Shakeela. It was in the year 2000 that her first Malayalam movie Kinnara... Read More...
Archiving the Complex Genealogies of Caste and Sexuality: An Interview with Dr. Anjali Arondekar
Saturday, 10 June 2017
  Anjali Arondekar This interview emerged as a series of email exchanges between Rohan Arthur and Dr. Anjali Arondekar who works on the Gomantak Maratha Samaj archives, following Rohan's... Read More...
Some of us will have to fight all our lives: Anoop Kumar
Thursday, 20 July 2017
  Anoop Kumar (This is the transcipt of his speech at the celebrations of the 126th Birth Anniversary of Dr. Babasaheb Amebdkar in Ras Al Khaimah organised by Ambedkar International... Read More...