Whose nation is it anyway?


Rahi Gaikwad

rahi gaikwad 1I remember a chapter in my class ten SSC (State Secondary Certificate) board textbook. It was an excerpt from Nehru's 'Discovery of India'. The passage spoke of Nehru's idea of India; it is perhaps among the best known lines of the book.

Nehru said, "All of us I suppose, have varying pictures of our native land and no two persons will think exactly alike. When I think of India, I think of many things: of broad fields dotted with innumerable small villages, of towns and cities I have visited; of the magic of the rainy season which pours life into the dry parched-up land and converts it suddenly into a glistening expanse of beauty and greenery, of great rivers and the flowing water; of the Khyber Pass in all its bleak surroundings; of the southern tip of India; of people, individually and in the mass; and above all, of the Himalayas, snow-capped, or some mountain valley in Kashmir in the spring, covered with new flowers, and with a brook bubbling and gurgling through it. We make and preserve the pictures of our choice, and so I have chosen this mountain background rather than the normal picture of a hot, sub-tropical country. Both pictured would be correct, for India stretches from the tropics right up to the temperate regions, from near the equator to the cold heart of Asia."

Every time I read this passage then as a student, I felt captivated by the beauty and intensity of Nehru's poetic imagery.

Not everyone can imagine his/her native land in this way. It takes the power of privilege to imagine a vast geography and speak on behalf of a deeply divided people; to be able to feel moved by the beauty of a flower or a brook and connect it to national pride.

I guess the untouchables of Mahad in Maharashtra would have been able to praise the sweetness of the 'Chavdar' (tasty) lake. But first they had to taste its water. For that they had to launch a satyagraha led by Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar in 1927.

Dr. Ambedkar also spoke of an idea of India – a possibility to be achieved rather than what was in existence. Far from a personal idyll, his Constituent Assembly speech on 25th November, 1949, raises more concerns about the Indian nationhood itself.

Dr. Ambedkar said: "I remember the days when politically-minded Indians, resented the expression "the people of India". They preferred the expression "the Indian nation." I am of opinion that in believing that we are a nation, we are cherishing a great delusion. How can people divided into several thousands of castes be a nation? The sooner we realize that we are not as yet a nation in the social and psychological sense of the world, the better for us. For then only we shall realize the necessity of becoming a nation and seriously think of ways and means of realizing the goal...In India there are castes. The castes are anti-national. In the first place because they bring about separation in social life. They are anti-national also because they generate jealousy and antipathy between caste and caste. But we must overcome all these difficulties if we wish to become a nation in reality."

A nation is thus possible only by the annihilation of caste – a central requirement for nationhood.

His speech was not taught in any school textbook, at least when I was a student. So I can say that for a long time I was delusional. Perhaps that was the intention.

The idea of India consumes the range of discourse from left to right. Upper caste ideologues have defined nationalism and anti-nationalism both, based on their respective ideologies and political stances, putting the question of caste to the periphery. By and large, among them, they have fixed the contours of what gets termed a national discourse. To be able to define, label and conflate your political interests with nationalism is a sign of caste privilege.

It is in this context that I see the JNU protests. After Rohith Vemula's death there was a semblance of a larger debate on caste and an indication that Dalit mobilization was becoming stronger. With the arrest and attack on Kanhaiya Kumar and the journalists in the Patiala House court the tide has turned. Exit caste, enter free speech.

The countless struggles of the Dalit bahujans pre- and post-independence have little to do with the binaries of the left and right, the notions of national and anti-national or concerns such as sedition and free speech. What is free speech to the scores of Dalit and adivasi children who have no platform to articulate their realities using their own agency? Who needs the threat of sedition when you can get killed in a caste massacre?

As a member of the media, I am of course disturbed by the attack on journalists in court and equally appalled by the attack on Kanhaiya Kumar and the students.

However, the national versus anti-national discourse defined by the self-proclaimed revolutionary university JNU and the Indian right in television and print debates, is, to refer to Dr. Ambedkar's view, delusion-inducing and self-serving.

The Dalit bahujan articulation is an anti-caste discourse, which never assumes a national stature. On the other hand, what we are seeing at JNU is an intra-caste discourse, which easily gets pitted as a national discourse.

Nearly 67 years after Dr. Ambedkar's speech, caste stands on firm the ground. There is a rise in the number of caste crimes. A large swathe of Dalit population continues to be landless and lives in one room houses. ('Dalits still left out' - Christophe Jafferlot, Indian Express).

In this backdrop, if the nation debates nationalism, the question that comes to mind is whose nation is it anyway.



Rahi Gaikwad is a journalist based in Mumbai.

Other Related Articles

Support Mahabodhi Residential School in Mizoram
Tuesday, 12 December 2017
  Sudip Chakma Dear Friends, I am very glad and excited to be connected with you through this media, from a remote Village, Tuichawng in Lunglei District Mizoram, India. Our school, Mahabodhi... Read More...
Embracing my Dalit-hood while rejoicing in accomplishments
Tuesday, 12 December 2017
  Chandramohan S During the award ceremony of M. Harish Govind Prize, many asked me why I need a "Dalit Poet" labeling. They were shocked that there were just a handful of Dalit poets who write... Read More...
Caste system and the chains of mind
Tuesday, 12 December 2017
  Tereza Menšíková Visiting India was my dream since childhood. Many stories were told by journalists, travelers, and fiction writers about the mysterious land of Mother India and they... Read More...
Call for Papers: “Doing Ambedkarism Today: Issues of Caste, Gender and Community”
Monday, 11 December 2017
  Call for papers for workshop on: “Doing Ambedkarism Today: Issues of Caste, Gender, and Community” Dates – 19th to 22nd February 2018 Deadline for Proposals – 31st December... Read More...
Arguing for ‘Feminist Ambedkarism’
Sunday, 10 December 2017
  Mahipal Mahamatta I am very glad to introduce to you an important work from Maharashtra, "स्त्रीवादी आंबेडकरवाद" (Feminist Ambedkarism), written by... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Index of Articles in Features
Sunday, 30 July 2017
  2017 ~ Crossing Caste Boundaries: Bahujan Representation in the Indian Women's Cricket Team by Sukanya Shantha ~ Dalit University: do we need it? by Vikas Bagde ~ The beautiful feeling of... Read More...
No Mr. Tharoor, I Don’t Want to Enter Your Kitchen
Saturday, 16 September 2017
Tejaswini Tabhane Shashi Tharoor is an author, politician and former international civil servant who is also a Member of Parliament representing the constituency of Thiruvananthapuram, Kerala. This... Read More...
Why Not Janeu Under My Kurta?
Wednesday, 09 August 2017
  Rahmath EP Lipstick Under My Burkha is a ‘by the Brahmin for the Brahmin' movie to propagate the Savarna definition of the ‘oppressed women’. The whole movie gives you a clear picture of... Read More...
A Peep into the Soft Porn Film Industry of Keralam
Friday, 30 June 2017
  Anilkumar PV The setting of the last millennium saw the rise of a new star in the horizon of Malayalam film industry: Shakeela. It was in the year 2000 that her first Malayalam movie Kinnara... Read More...
Some of us will have to fight all our lives: Anoop Kumar
Thursday, 20 July 2017
  Anoop Kumar (This is the transcipt of his speech at the celebrations of the 126th Birth Anniversary of Dr. Babasaheb Amebdkar in Ras Al Khaimah organised by Ambedkar International... Read More...