<SiteLock

Is Islamic caste system entirely a Hindu influence?

 

Shafiullah Anis

shafi 1Various scholars have worked on casteism among Muslims starting with the premise that casteism among Muslims is an influence of "Hindu" caste structure present for centuries in Indian sub-continent. In this context, Imtiaz Ahmed (Ahmed, 2018) poses an interesting question: 'If caste among Muslims owed itself entirely to Hindu influence, then the Islamization of Muslim groups over the centuries should have resulted in the slow and gradual elimination of caste principles and ideology. However, such evidences as is available suggest that Islamization serves to reinforce rather than weaken or eliminate caste distinctions.'

It would be an interesting exercise to understand the process of reification of the inegalitarian caste system within an alleged egalitarian Islamic culture, but before that it is important to understand whether this inegalitarianism has its source in Hindu culture through the process of acculturation and mixing, or the immigrant Muslims brought some inegalitarian values with them that found a suitable breeding ground in the hierarchical society of the Indian sub-continent.

In this direction, Ahmed has indicated towards the aporias within Islamic Jurisprudence that suggest that the popular idea of egalitarianism of Islam may not successfully pass the scrutiny. "This emphasis upon birth and ancestry acquired acceptance in Islamic law as time went by, (Prophet) Muhammad, whose statement 'There are no genealogies in Islam' is widely cited as evidence of his belief in equality of all believers, himself suggested that considerations of birth should receive special attention in the instance of marriage. According to a tradition, he is supposed to have taught, 'Take ye care, that none contract in marriage but their proper guardians, and that they be not so contracted except with equals' (Bukhari, 1862:436). Basing themselves on this very principle, Muslim jurists worked out an elaborate scheme of social grades and descent. Thus, according to Hanafiites, six elements were necessary to produce equality of status of which descent was most important..."

Ahmed finds similar obsession of lineage and birth among Shafi'i school in designating social hierarchies. Though, Maliki school, having their African influence, didn't succumb to such distinctions as per his observations.

Despite the presence of lineage and birth as an important feature in determining the social worth of a person by various Islamic Jurisprudence, Ahmed fails to agree with Khan (Khan, 1968) who opines that "even if there were no caste influence on Muslim peasantries in India and Pakistan, the social structure would still be as rigidly stratified as it is now, resulting from a strict adherence to precedent recognized by Islamic societies as well as Islamic jurisprudence".

Imtiaz Ahmed relies on the lack of evidence of social stratification in Muslim world beyond the sub-continent on his disagreement. He emphatically disagrees with Khan's thesis. That Muslim caste owes itself directly to Hindu influence is his final conclusion. In this discussion, Ahmed has left many questions unanswered. Firstly, the few sources cited by Khan (1968) as evidence1 of a stratified society outside Indian sub-continent were not considered sufficient by Ahmed.

Secondly, the recent works on Sayyidism, Ashrafization and the presence of lineage based social stratification in Muslim society outside the sub-continent that have emphatically established the presence of elite classes that are endogamous, marked by lineage and birth, enjoying special social status and connecting themselves with the Prophet and his family (Corsi, 2004; Kazuo, 2012) are not referred by Ahmed. These works have successfully established that there is a distinction available to these lineage-based elites within the normative Islam as well as the society they live in. The discourse of egalitarianism and of lineage-based elites run parallel within the norm as well as practice.

~

Notes

1. References cited by Khan in support of presence of social hierarchy in various muslim societies: B. Spuler, "Iran and Islam," American Anthropologist (April, 1956), 50.;W. Dostal: "Paria-Gruppen in Vorderasien," Zeitschrift fur Ethnologic (1964), 192; H. J. Henninger, Paria-Stamme in ArabienFestchriftzum 50 juhrigenBestands-jubilaum des Missionshauses St. Cabriel (Wien-Modllng, 1939), 501-539; Ibn' Khaldun, The Muqaddimuh, tr. Franz Rozenthal (New York, 1958), II,305-305.

References

Ahmed, I. (2018). Caste and Social Stratification among Muslims in India. Delhi: Aakar Books.

Corsi, M. (2004). Oriente Moderno. Anno ISLAM IN SOUTH ASIA, 23(1), 39–49. Retrieved from http://www.jstor.org/stable/25817916%5Cnhttp://about.jstor.org/terms

Kazuo, M. (2012). Sayyids and sharifs in Muslim societies: The living links to the Prophet. Sayyids and Sharifs in Muslim Societies: The Living Links to the Prophet, 1–276. https://doi.org/10.4324/9780203123157

 Khan, ZR (1968). Caste and Muslim Peasantries of North India, (1).

~~~

 

Shafiullah Anis is an IIM Lucknow alumnus, working as Head, Glocal Business School, and his research area is the Marketplace, Society, and Culture.
Email: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Other Related Articles

The Real Remedy for Breaking Caste
Tuesday, 22 September 2020
  Dhamma Darshan Nigam   “I am convinced that the real remedy is inter-marriage. Fusion of blood can alone create the feeling of being kith and kin, and unless this feeling of kinship, of... Read More...
Lineage and Caste in Islam
Sunday, 20 September 2020
  Shafiullah Anis   (Round Table India and SAVARI have been hosting a series of online talks by activists and thinkers on issues of importance to the Bahujan. This is the... Read More...
The Journey of School Education for Bahujan and Impact of NEP 2020
Friday, 18 September 2020
  Naaz Khair   The National Education Policy, 2020 (NEP2020) has been approved by the Union Cabinet as of 29th July, 2020. The National Education Policies of 1968, 1986 and Plan of Action... Read More...
“Mannu”: A documentary turns Munnar upside down
Wednesday, 16 September 2020
  Srutheesh Kannadi Munnar has always been a place of attraction for tourists around the world because of the presence of the Western Ghats, climate and other geographical distinctiveness. The... Read More...
For the perfect progressive recipe, skip caste, sprinkle Dalit swadanusaar: Gaurav Somwanshi
Friday, 11 September 2020
  Gaurav Somwanshi (Round Table India and SAVARI have been hosting a series of online talks by activists and thinkers on issues of importance to the Bahujan. This is the transcript of Gaurav... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Feminism is Brahminism
Saturday, 30 May 2020
Anu Ramdas This is the transcript of a preliminary talk on the topic of feminism is brahminism. First, thank you. It is so lovely to see all of you. Thank you for the opportunity. And I am not at all... Read More...
Why Dr. Devi Shetty’s 25 (or 2500) ‘ways to manage Covid-19’ should be rejected outright
Tuesday, 07 April 2020
  Dr. Sylvia Karpagam For far too long, Dr. Devi Shetty has been giving advice on a range of things, the most recent being the Covid-19 pandemic. This is a crucial public health period for... Read More...
How the Brahmin beat Corona
Sunday, 05 April 2020
  Kuffir (Round Table India is doing a series to put together the Bahujan perspective on the Coronavirus pandemic) Anu Ramdas: I would like to ask two questions. First, the updates you posted on... Read More...
Is there a space for North-Eastern identity among students' politics in Indian Universities?
Thursday, 23 April 2020
  Thangminlal (Lalcha) Haokip My colleagues have often asked me why University students from the North East do not take an active part in students' politics in mainland Indian Universities.... Read More...
Open Letter to the CM of Maharashtra - Immediate Assistance to COVID-19 affected Slums
Thursday, 02 April 2020
  Date: 1st April, 2020 To,Hon'ble Chief Minister and Hon’ble Deputy Chief Minister,Government of Maharashtra Subject: Immediate Assistance for COVID19 affected people in Mumbai slum areas The... Read More...