Caste in the Name of Christ: An angry note on the Syrian Christian Caste

 

Nidhin Shobhana

n shobhanaFor many days now, I have been grappling with a strong sense of unrest within me. I am thankful to the recent debates on Arundhati Roy and her mighty long introduction to 'S. Anand's critically annotated Annihilation of Caste' which inspired me to finally ventilate this unrest. Oops! I forgot to mention the real author's name, Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar. This is what big names like 'Arundhati Roy' do to you... you miss the real author's name!

Having acknowledged the inspiration, I would like to make it clear that this article is not about Arundhati Roy. It's addressed to my Syrian Christian Brethren. It's lovingly addressed to those Nazranis who strongly feel that they should write about caste and 'annihilate caste'.

Let's start with an informed recognition of where does one come from in this caste society. A closer look at the Syrian Christian community exposes caste, at least at three levels. Firstly, there is a caste hierarchy which operates within them. Secondly, they place themselves at the top of, what I call the 'Christian Caste Hierarchy'. Now this is very clear, when we converse with them. A repeated mention of their Brahmin origins will often decorate the conversation. In fact, economically well-to-do, aging Syrian Christians, will document such farfetched connections in their autobiographies. One such little known Malayalam autobiography is of a deceased communist leader from my home district, Wayanad. In his autobiography, titled 'From Cross to Sickle' he talks about the revolutionary transformations in his life, as the title suggests. However, in the first three chapters, he painstakingly pulls the Brahmin thread from his ancestry. I often wonder what would have been his thoughts about the 'other' Christian denominations, emerging from Dalit-Bahujan experiences. Thirdly, in the general schema of caste they have been the chauffeurs of the Master Brahmins. They have operated as an important link which connects Savarna pride with Avarna oppression. In this process, they have constructed their own pride which stands shamelessly on the avarna's toil. Now, in my limited knowledge, I have come across very few academic endeavors which talk directly about these caste ladders. It's indeed significant to state at this juncture that a rigorous Ambedkarite analysis and historiography of this powerful group is yet to come. However, when we read between the lines, we see the caste devil smiling sweetly.

The academic literature produced on Syrian Christians can be broadly classified into two groups. The first group claims to be engaged in passionate anthropological research, somewhat like the early ethnographers and orientalists. Under the garb of 'research for research sake' they sanction and sanctify racist and casteist explanations of their existence. They sound apolitical. But do not get carried away so soon. By not talking about caste aesthetics, conflicts, oppression and slavery they uphold a unique identity which inspires awe. The second group very clearly has a conservationist approach. They would like to 'preserve' this caste in all its colours. And while doing so they would make dangerous connections. For example, in a Malayalam book I read recently, the author connects Syrian Christians with Kashmiri Pandits, Patels of Gujarat, Tamil Brahmins; Chitpavan Brahmins so on and so forth. His argument clearly states that all these groups have Jewish ancestry and have historically been arms of the ruling castes and classes. Now, can it get more interesting! In yet another book titled 'Syrian Christians: Many faces, One Tradition' the author proudly states that Syrian Christians are 'Christians by Faith; Hindus by Culture and Oriental in their worship'.

poykayil appachan

Poykayil Johannan, or Poikayil Appachan, who first rebelled against caste in the church

Let's also remember that this community has the highest land ownership in the state of Kerala. Scholars like Sunny Kappikad, K.K. Kochu, Prof. Sanal Mohan and Prof. Kunhaman have written about the material abundance of this community.

Historically, this caste group which developed into one of the major business bania castes in Kerala eventually displaced the Buddhist and Jain traders who were challenging the Brahmanical Order. Under the happy patronage of the Master Brahmins this group enjoyed many privileges. There is evidence to prove that they had their own caste armies, they were given powers to control, exploit and violate many 'lower castes', slave castes who served them. They were given greater spatial liberties. The knowledge of world trade and control over the cultivation and trade of cash crops proved to be a boon for this community. Christianity never witnessed a radical egalitarian interpretation in this community. It was only when Christianity came in contact with slave castes and Dalits that the liberatory possibilities of the faith were actualized.

Having said that, I would argue, that the process of 'writing caste' for Syrian Christians should start with a detailed recovery of their own histories from anti-caste perspectives. This means that they should ask the following questions – (a) Beyond simply mentioning one's caste location, what does being a Syrian Christian mean? It's important to nail down and expose the identity politics of the powerful (b) How does one talk about one's privileges and hatred? (c) What are the contemporary manifestations of Syrian Christian racism and casteism? (d) How does one 'own' the dehumanizing privileges of caste? (e) How does one link the everyday of 'Syrian Christianhood' with communities who are situated above and below them in the caste hierarchy? (f) How does one forge dialogues which threaten one's caste pride? I am sure my Syrian Christian sisters and brothers would add many more questions.

If this does not happen, and if Syrian Christians choose to be like the 'lengthy introducer' whom I mentioned in the beginning, they would keep repeating their caste-ordained role. In the introduction, a Christian Bania talks about a Hindu Bania under the pretext of introducing Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar. In Kerala, till a few years back, if grains and oil were to be brought to a Namboothiri household by the lower castes, it had to travel through the Syrian Christian household. The traditional role of purification continues in the case of this introduction. An upper caste audience can consume a self-sufficient radical text only when a Syrian Christian performs the caste ordained purification ritual. Since they have the knowledge of world trade they would even market the text. This process is dangerous.

If the images of caste continue in new forms, it would hurt all of us. If the Syrian Christian, armed with words, is waiting for the 'Dalit Revolution' so that she can encash it, we need to be very careful and alert to expose her. For them, 'Dalit' becomes an all encompassing catchword to understand caste. This should be challenged. The urge to constantly evaluate dalits, their universal literature and their democratic social movements should be seen as an 'upper-caste indulgence'. It should be 'engagement' and not 'evaluation'. This engagement should compulsorily implicate you in the text. What is required is, borrowing from bell hooks, a process of 'self-actualization'; an 'anti-caste self actualization' which threatens and destroys us, in an attempt to reshape us. It's my earnest request to all Syrian Christians and their friends to breathe freely and open their own rooms and clean up the dirt. This work would be historic!

~

Please also read other articles on a related issue:

The Not-So-Intimate Enemy: The Loss and Erasure of the Self Under Casteism: by Gee Imaan Semmalar

Flaunting noble intentions, nurturing caste privileges: by Asha Kowtal

The Question of Free Speech: by Vaibhav Wasnik

Arundhati Roy replies to Dalit Camera

An Open Letter to Ms. Arundhati Roy: by Dalit Camera

Vedic Chants for the 21st Century

Arundhati Roy's 'Introduction' to Ambedkar: Inside one Misogynistic & Xenophobic Dalit's mind: by Anoop Kumar

The Judge, the Jury and the Goddess: by Akshay Pathak

Resisting a messiah: by Anoop Kumar

An Introduction to Anoop Kumar's "Misogynistic and Xenophobic Rants": by Vinay Bhat

~~~

 

Nidhin Shobhana works with Krantijyoti Savitribai Phule Women's Studies Centre, Dnyanjyoti Savitribai Phule University, Pune.

Image Courtesy: Tasveer Ghar.

Other Related Articles

The ‘Dalit’ President and the question of representation
Sunday, 25 June 2017
  Kadhiravan The year was 2009, I was in my final year – under graduation and there happened a week-long orientation towards facing campus placements. In one of the group sessions, a debate on... Read More...
'The Manu Smriti mafia still haunts us': A speech by a Pakistani Dalit Rights Leader
Thursday, 15 June 2017
  Surendar Valasai Probably the first comprehensive political statement for Dalit rights in Pakistan framed in the vocabulary of Dalitism was given in 2007 by Surendar Valasai, who is now the... Read More...
The difference in being a Babasaheb and a Pandit
Monday, 29 May 2017
  Tejaswini Tabhane The following tweet has made all my nerves rebel. I am restless. I am constantly wondering what my identity is. I am not able to digest this hatred. I am surprised how anyone... Read More...
Atrocities on Dalits and Rights to Self Defence
Friday, 26 May 2017
  Deepak Kumar The Indian Constitution envisaged the words of Buddha, "war is not the solution", in its text and other legislative provisions. The Indian Constitution in Part IV makes the... Read More...
Release of 'What Babasaheb Ambedkar Means to Me' eBook: Get your free copy!
Wednesday, 17 May 2017
  The Shared Mirror Publishing House We are happy to share news of the release of our second book. 'What Babasaheb Means to Me' is an edited volume that compiles articles by authors on Round... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Interview with Prof Khalid Anis Ansari on the Pasmanda Movement
Monday, 27 February 2017
  Round Table India In this episode of the Ambedkar Age series, Round Table India talks to Prof. Khalid Anis Ansari, Director, Dr. Ambedkar Centre for Exclusion Studies & Transformative... Read More...
Maratha Kranti (Muk) Morcha: When will Maratha women cross the threshold?
Friday, 20 January 2017
Sandhya Gawali Maratha Community has been organizing massive silent rallies (muk morcha) in various districts in a strong display of restlessness. The immediate reason behind the march is the brutal... Read More...
The Rise of the Bheem Army
Saturday, 13 May 2017
  Vinay Shende Exclusive details on the recent caste incidents in Saharanpur, Uttar Pradesh, and the role of the Bheem Army. This report is based on a member speaking to Round Table India on the... Read More...
Love and Marriage: Caste and Social Spaces
Monday, 13 February 2017
  Kadhiravan ~ An ideal society should be mobile, should be full of channels for conveying a change taking place in one part to other parts. In an ideal society there should be many interests... Read More...
UP में गाय माता तो सुरक्षित है लेकिन दलित माताओं का क्या...?
Sunday, 09 April 2017
  शोभना स्मृति एवं कुलदीप कुमार बौद्ध  भारत को आजाद हुए 70 साल बीत गए... Read More...