Speech and the Speaker's Identity


Tejas Harad

tejas haradIn 2016, famous Indian author Chetan Bhagat published a novel called One Indian Girl. This book was criticised by some women because the book's narrator, who is also its protagonist, is a woman. Bhagat, even though a man, is within his rights to have a woman narrator in his novel. But it is unfair to say that he cannot be criticised for the same. It is one thing to not let someone publish a book or ask for its ban after publication, and another to criticise someone for writing a particular book. There is a reason why academic criticism from the angle of 'identity' (in this case gender) has increased over the decades.

Men wrote androcentric literature. Women were invisibilized and silenced. They were not allowed to write, their contributions were erased, and they were stereotyped and derided in literature. The contribution of Savitribai Phule is still not acknowledged outside Ambedkarite movement. When Tarabai Shinde's tract A Comparison between Women and Men was published in 1882, she faced immense backlash. George Eliot aka Mary Ann Evans had to write under a male pen name. Women still do not easily find a place in shortlists of book prizes. Therefore, if Chetan Bhagat, known for his sexism, is criticised for writing a book from a woman's point of view, it shouldn't come as a surprise.

Today, marginalised groups are fighting various kinds of oppressions — from patriarchy, race, caste, heteronormativity to ableism. Oppressed groups are using the same identity relations that are the cause of their exploitation, for offering a wholesome analysis of social structures. So 'identity' becomes the primary tool through which they view the world, understand relations of production and forces of production, understand their oppression, and also challenge it. Identity politics intends to achieve three main immediate objectives: one, unity of the oppressed on a given identity axis — such as caste — through raising consciousness; two, increased representation in various spheres of society; and three, the power to define themselves.

Whenever the oppressed criticise knowledge production through the lens of identity, we hear the "free speech" argument. "One should be allowed to write on whatever topic they want. After all, more the voices the merrier!" But what this argument misses is the unequal playing field. Brahmins have easier access to newspapers, magazines, news websites, TV channels and publishing houses. Therefore, there are more Brahmins talking about every issue in this country than any other caste group, even though Brahmins constitute only 3-4% of the population. This makes the discourse impoverished and one dimensional. The critique of Brahminism and the issues that are critical to Bahujan lives are hardly given space.

But my concern is not only the identity of the speaker but also the content of their speech. The problem is not that the speaker is a Brahmin. The problem is that Brahmins have historically erased, silenced, misrepresented and stereotyped non-Brahmins; and they have monopolised spaces of discussion and literary production. Oppressors routinely misrepresent the oppressed, malign them and skirt the root cause of the oppression. The binary of the "normative" and the "Other" is useful here. In this world, white cismen are the norm, everybody else is the Other. In India, Brahmin cismen are the norm, everybody else is the Other. Groups which are the norm partake in the world's affairs without carrying any label; it is the "Others" who are reminded of their identity at every step of their existence. It is futile to expect those on the right side of the identity to understand how exactly the "Other" lives their life. However empathetic one is, one cannot fully grasp the lived reality of the "Other." Therefore, the discussions around the speech and identity of the speaker cannot be easily dismissed.



Tejas Harad works in the copy editing department at Economic and Political Weekly. His interest lies in studying the intersection of Ambedkarism, feminism and theoretical Marxism.

Other Related Articles

Mahatma Phule's Thoughts on Caste-Patriarchy: A Critical Evaluation
Thursday, 16 November 2017
  Sachin Garud It is a well-known fact that at the time of India's national movement, there was another movement known as the movement of social engineering or social revolution, led by Mahatma... Read More...
Celebrating 7th November as Students' Day
Friday, 10 November 2017
  Rahul Pagare The government of Maharashtra declared 7th of November to be celebrated as Students' Day on the occasion of Dr. Babasaheb Ambedkar's first day of school entry, back in 1900 AD.... Read More...
Surveillance and Punishment in the Village: Reflections on Imayam’s Pethavan
Thursday, 09 November 2017
  Karthick RM "Hence the major effect of the Panopticon: to induce in the inmate a state of conscious and permanent visibility that assures the automatic functioning of power."-Michel Foucault... Read More...
Chamcha Leadership or Conscious Leadership?
Wednesday, 01 November 2017
  Rajanikanta Gochhayat Representation simply means acting and representing opinion/interest on behalf of the people. In the Indian context, Representation is divided into two categories: one,... Read More...
Dalit Women Speak Out- A Conference
Monday, 30 October 2017
  Asha Kowtal The swift changes in the political landscape and the challenges faced by women human rights defenders often pushes us Dalit women into a vortex of greater insecurity, fear and... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Some of us will have to fight all our lives: Anoop Kumar
Thursday, 20 July 2017
  Anoop Kumar (This is the transcipt of his speech at the celebrations of the 126th Birth Anniversary of Dr. Babasaheb Amebdkar in Ras Al Khaimah organised by Ambedkar International... Read More...
Cow, ‘backwardness’ and ‘Bahujan’ Women
Monday, 10 July 2017
  Asha Singh  My Ahir-dominant village in Bhojpur district of Bihar has a school only up to standard seven. After the seventh grade, if somebody (or their family) decides to study further,... Read More...
The beautiful feeling of falling in love with a Bahujan Ambedkarite
Friday, 28 July 2017
  Priya This is not going to be a long write-up, the sole purpose of writing this is to share the beautiful revolutionary feeling that we derive when we have fallen in love or have driven... Read More...
An urban adivasi’s perspective on Newton
Thursday, 12 October 2017
  Nolina Minj India's official entry to the Oscars, Newton has done well for itself in the box-office. Critics have described it as 'brilliant, subversive and one of the finest political satires... Read More...
I Take Responsibility
Wednesday, 28 June 2017
  Swati Kamble Since the BJP government came to power in India in 2014, masses with extreme Hindu ideology and strong anti-Muslim and anti-Dalit sentiments are using brutal force to terrorize... Read More...