Election of Kamala Harris: Is America half a century behind South Asia?


Prof Vivek Kumar

vivek-kumarOn January 20, 2021, Kamala Harris created a history of sorts by taking oath as America's first female Vice President. She is the first woman of South Asian and Afro-American descent who has received such an honor. This may be a historic moment for Americans. However, if we analyze this history a little more deeply we will find that it is not so historic a moment in American democracy as it is being made out to be.

The obvious reason is that the United States of America is the oldest democracy in the world. If we consider the beginning of democracy here since 1788, when the US Constitution was approved by the states, then we will find that in the 233 year old history of democracy, America has not yet elected a single woman to the highest office of the nation.

We cannot treat this American success as great, because this success of America has come 60 years late as compared to South Asia. It is to be remembered here that a woman was sworn in as head of state in 1960 in Sri Lanka (known as Ceylon at that time), which was just a small emerging democracy in South Asia.

Even if you take India as compared to America, then here too in 1966, that is, about half a century ago, a woman was sworn in as the leader of the elected government of the nation. Not only this, a woman was sworn in as head of the country in 1988 and 1991 in Pakistan and Bangladesh respectively in South Asia, almost thirty years earlier than America's election of a woman to the second highest office of the country. But even today, no woman has been sworn in as the head of the country (President) in democratic America.

 Hence on this basis, we can easily argue that the oldest democracy in the world is at least half a century behind the democratic countries of South Asia.

For factual and precise information on July 21, 1960, Sirimavo Bandaranaike, became the world's first female head of nation from South Asia. In all, in different stints, she ruled her country for 17 years and created history. After Sri Lanka, Indira Gandhi of India became the female head of the nation via an elected government in January 1966. She also ruled the country for nearly 15 years on various occasions, before her assassination on 31 October 1984. Throughout the period when Indira Gandhi was at the helm of affairs she not only had complete control over her political party but she also had complete control over the country's politics. Can we say the same for Kamala Harris in US?

In South Asia, in Pakistan also, Benazir Bhutto became the head of State on 2 December 1988. In fact, she became the first female head of any State among the Muslim majority nations of the world. She also became the Prime Minister of Pakistan for the second time during 1993–1996. On the other hand, in the Muslim world itself, Khaleda Zia was sworn in as the first female Prime Minister of Bangladesh on 20 March 1991 and another woman politician, Sheikh Hasina, became the second woman to be sworn in as Prime Minister of Bangladesh on 23 June 1996.  In fact Sheikh Hasina is currently the longest-serving Prime Minister of Bangladesh.

The legacy of the women heads of state in South Asia was carried forward by Chandrika Kumaratunga, the daughter of Sirimavo Bandaranaike, the first woman head of the State in the world. She went on to become the first female President of Sri Lanka in November 1995, but left politics after the assassination attempt on her in 1999 by LTTE.

Here, it would be expedient to mention the names of directly/indirectly elected formal heads of South Asian countries such as India and Nepal. For example, Pratibha Devisingh Patil was sworn in as the first woman President of India in July 2007, while Bidhya Devi Bhandari as the first female President of Nepal in October 2015. Has this been possible in America so far? So we can observe ourselves, the number of woman heads in South Asia has been growing.

Will Black, Latino, Native American, and Muslim women in America or Dalit, Tribal, Pasmanda women in South Asia reach the highest office of their Nations?

Although, women are being elected to the top most posts, in the US and South Asian countries, yet the women of both the regions face challenges. From the point of view of social movements and social change, it is pertinent to record the challenges as well.

 America has to succeed in electing its first woman to the highest post of the nation, and a self-sufficient/independent woman in South Asia has to succeed in the election to the highest post of the country. Self-sufficient/independent here means a woman without any political patronage and not belonging to any political dynasty.

We are aware that in South Asia, women who have been elected to the highest posts in their nations have carried forward the political legacy of their father or husband. For example, in 1959 Sirimavo Bandaranaike, captured the then highest office of nation riding at the back of sympathy wave after her husband, S. W. R. D. Bandarnaike's murder. In the same vein, Khaleda Zia could capture the reigns of Bangladesh National Party, and thereby the highest office of the land because of the sympathy wave created by her husband's assassination in 1981. Indira Gandhi, Benazir Bhutto, Sheikh Hasina too have all carried forward the legacy of their fathers, Jawaharlal Nehru, Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto and Sheikh Mujibur Rahman respectively. In Sri Lanka, Chandrika Kumaratunga got the legacy of both her mother and father.

From the point of view of contemporary politics, social change and social movements, if we assess the election of women to the highest offices in America and South Asia, then we can get a few more points for consideration. In the context of America, an Afro-American woman who is a product of the black movement--like Black Panthers-- has yet to establish herself in the mainstream politics of America. Kamala Harris does not represent that identity.

It is well known that throughout the US Presidential elections 2020, Kamala Harris's mother's South Asian (Indian) and her father's Jamaican or Afro-American identities were exploited to attract Indians and Afro-Americans to the Democratic Party.

However, on the basis of sociology of identity it would be difficult to believe that Indians living in America would not have associated themselves with Kamala Harris's mother's Tamil Brahmin identity. Therefore, although Kamala Harris may be seen representing women in American politics, but in reality she does not represent excluded, black, Latino, Red Indian and poor, etc., women of United States of America.

Similarly, women born in Sri Lanka, India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Nepal etc., who were/are elected to the highest offices of the land, also belong to so-called higher castes and definitely to higher class, with support of the status quoist forces. They too do not come from Dalit, Adivasi, and within minorities, the Pasmanda society.

In South Asia, we have to analyze whether these women leaders represented or are giving representation to other women as the heads of their political parties - like Indira Gandhi, Shrimao Bhandarnayake, Benazir Bhutto, Sheikh Hasina, Chandrika Kumaratunga etc.. If not then, how can we celebrate them?

Will the world's oldest and world's largest democracies, by electing excluded women to the highest office in their respective country's politics, set an example for many other countries of the world, especially for the countries of South Asia, and strengthen the democracies throughout the world? We will wait for this happy moment in this decade of the 21st century.



Prof Vivek Kumar is Prof of Sociology at the Centre for the Study of Social Systems/ Jawaharlal Nehru University, and Public Intellectual. Views expressed are personal.

Other Related Articles

Unnao after Hathras: Atrocities, again and again
Monday, 22 February 2021
Sonali Shirke In Baburha village, Unnao district, of Uttar Pradesh, a horrific incident of atrocities against Dalit girls has once again come to light on February 17 (many such incidents happen every... Read More...
Re-Imagining Justice: From Punitive to Transformative
Monday, 22 February 2021
Pranav Jeevan P Before we start talking about different forms of Criminal Justice systems that are existing and that can be created, we need to sneak a peek into the current carceral Criminal Justice... Read More...
1921, Mappila and the idea of a nation
Wednesday, 17 February 2021
Bobby Kunhu Despite the extensive work by historians like K. N. Panikkar, the general consensus that the 1921 Malabar rebellion was a peasant rebellion and the fact that the Government of Kerala... Read More...
Politics beyond Pity: Looking at the condemnation of the events of Republic Day, 2021
Friday, 12 February 2021
  Naichashakh (नैचाशाख) The farmer's protests which managed to persuasively register themselves in early November as the farmer groups and unions moved past the barricades, heavy... Read More...
Tandav, A Plot to Suppress the Ideological Space of Phule Ambedkarites
Wednesday, 10 February 2021
  Ajay Choudhary Indian society, which is plagued by caste discrimination, is often triggered by emotional and sentimental issues. The prevailing unscientific and irrational formal education... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Lineage and Caste in Islam
Sunday, 20 September 2020
  Shafiullah Anis   (Round Table India and SAVARI have been hosting a series of online talks by activists and thinkers on issues of importance to the Bahujan. This is the... Read More...
Statement of Solidarity for Dr. Maroona Murmu from the Faculty of Presidency University
Monday, 07 September 2020
We, the undersigned teachers of Presidency University, Kolkata, are shocked to know about the recent attacks on Dr. Maroona Murmu, Associate Professor of History, Jadavpur University, Kolkata.... Read More...
The Ruling Caste's changing priorities and the Farmer Unrest
Tuesday, 08 December 2020
  Anshul Kumar “History shows that the Brahmin has always had other classes as his allies to whom he was ready to accord the status of a governing class provided they were prepared to work... Read More...
For the perfect progressive recipe, skip caste, sprinkle Dalit swadanusaar: Gaurav Somwanshi
Friday, 11 September 2020
  Gaurav Somwanshi (Round Table India and SAVARI have been hosting a series of online talks by activists and thinkers on issues of importance to the Bahujan. This is the transcript of Gaurav... Read More...
How to write anti-caste solidarity texts
Monday, 02 November 2020
Dr. Murali Shanmugavelan Ensure that “Dalit” appears as a prefix whenever the victim is mentioned. The phrase “Dalit victim” helps your readers understand the difference between Dalits and... Read More...