The Gita and OBCs


Kancha Ilaiah

kancha ilaiahNo Shudra-OBC can be a priest either in a Ram temple, a Krishna temple, or a Shiva temple. But he can be the Prime Minister of this country.

Today, when a Shudra-OBC is PM, it's not because of the Gita, but because of Ambedkar's Constitution.

 The Other Backward Classes are a historically oppressed majority in India. All debates on "Hindu nationalism" initiated by the brahminic forces assume that the Other Backward Classes, who constitute the largest social group in India are part of Hinduism. The dalits, Muslims and Christians keep on protesting, but the OBCs do not protest, not even when a senior leader of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party said recently that the Bhagavad Gita should be made India's "national scripture", replacing the Indian Constitution.

The OBCs voted for Narendra Modi, India's first OBC Prime Minister, in substantial numbers. But they have not got anything substantial from his elevation. Instead, the upper castes particularly brahmins and baniyas have got very visible positions in his ministry, and the baniya industry is booming ever since Mr Modi and Amit Shah took over the state apparatus and the BJP.

External affairs minister Sushma Swaraj's attempt to bring an act to declare the Bhagavad Gita as India's national scripture, that is, the conscious-keeper of India's government and its people, has far more serious implications than Sadhvi Niranjan Jyoti's obnoxious statement.

Ms Swaraj is a seasoned politician with a solid support from her caste, brahmin, whose strength in the Union Cabinet and state governments is increasing.

Most recently, Maharashtra and Haryana have been handed over to brahmin chief ministers. The Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh and the Vishwa Hindu Parishad seem to be working with a conscious agenda to bring the brahmin-baniya control back again.

The Gita debate helps that agenda. Along with the minority communities, the OBCs too would be big losers. Perhaps even more, since, unlike, Muslims and Christians, the OBCs do not have international recognition or backing.

A careful reading of the Gita would show anyone that it fully supports the enslavement of Shudras and OBCs, a process initiated by the Rig Veda itself. Rig Veda formulated the caste structure in Purusha Suktha and the Gita upheld it.

If the claim of the VHP is accepted (though there is no historical authenticity for that claim) that the Gita is 5,151 years old, it means that the enslavement of shudras is more than 5,000 years old.

No Shudra-OBC can be a priest either in a Ram temple, a Krishna temple, or a Vishnu or Shiva temple. But he can be the Prime Minister of this country. Today, when a Shudra-OBC is Prime Minister, it's not because of the Gita, but because of B.R. Ambedkar's Constitution.

In Bhagavad Gita, Krishna declares:

"Chaaturvarnyam mayaa srishtam gunakarma vibhaagashah"

(I have created four Varnas based on guna-karma guna means quality, karma means work.)

There are references to brahmins in the Gita as most revered social force created by Krishna to conduct spiritual affairs. The emphasis in Gita on performing each section's duty as assigned by the theory of Varna Dharma of Rig Veda is consistent. Krishna consciousness then is clearly caste consciousness.

Krishna also says: Krishigaurakshyavaanijyam vaishyakarma swabhaavajam;

Paricharyaatmakam karma shoodrasyaapi swabhaavajam.

(Agriculture, cattle-rearing and trade are the duties of the Vaishya based on their own karma and nature; and serving others is the duty of the Shudras based on their karma and nature.)

With this divine dictum Krishna sealed the fate of the Shudra-OBCs. Till today the fundamental social location of the Shudras has not changed in Hinduism.

The brahminic interpreters of the Gita say that the Varna system created by Krishna does not operate by birth, but is based on aptitude and skill. But for the last 5,000 years nobody's caste status has changed. The Indian Constitution began to effect that change. The present design to replace the Constitution with the Gita is to stop that.

On certain issues Gita appears to have taken a universalist position. Krishna's discourse on truth, renunciation, salvation, devotion, consciousness, existence and so on is universal in nature. But if the experience of the Shudra-OBCs and dalits (who do not figure in the Gita because they are out of the Varna/caste system) ever since Gita was composed is considered, then it's clear that the Gita is a text meant for only for the upper castes.

 In fact, though Arjuna asks transformative questions, Krishna's answers remain confined to assignment of caste-based duties. All those who interpret Gita from the point of view of karma yog try to give a positivist understanding of work ethics. But nowhere in the Gita does Krishna talks about productive work positively. His stress is more on fighting by Arjuna, not as individual soldier, but as a member of kshatriya caste, as part of Varna dharma.

From Vivekananda to Mahatma Gandhi to B.P. Mandal (who quoted extensively from Gita in the Mandal Commission Report), all of them mistook Krishna's reference to Varna duties to individual duties. But there is no scope of "spiritual individualism" in Gita as there is in Vinaya Pitaka, Bible or Quran or Guru Granth Sahib. The Gita only talks about caste moksha, not individual moksha.

Gita's position on caste is a major problem for all those who have suffered oppression. The discrimination here is not individual discrimination; it is a discrimination based on caste. Though untouchables (dalits) were not mentioned in the Gita, they are now part of caste system.

The Yadavs in north India, a powerful OBC community, consider Krishna as their community god. But they go by the story that he was brought up by a Yadav family and became the ruler of Yadu Rajya. Theirs is mainly physical worship of Krishna's body. I have not known any Yadava scholar of Gita telling the world that it is a liberative text for Yadavs, leave alone other Shudras-OBCs and dalits.

Yadav leaders like Mulayam Singh, Lalu Prasad, Sharad Yadav and so on should not be swayed by their admiration for Krishna and simplistic understanding of the Gita. They must join hands with M. Karunanidhi, Mamata Banerjee and the Left parties to stop all attempts at a brahminic resurgence as is being insidiously suggested by Ms Swaraj.

The writer is director, Centre for the Study of Social Exclusion and Inclusive Policy, Maulana Azad National Urdu University, Hyderabad

[Courtesy: The Asian Age, 12/22/14]

Other Related Articles

Govt. of India should send One Lakh SC ST youths abroad for Higher Education
Monday, 21 June 2021
  Anshul Kumar Men sitting on the pinnacle of the palace "So, I went one day to Linlithgow and said, concerning the expense of education, "If you will not get angry, I want to ask a question. I... Read More...
The Reddy-BC combination and the prospects of Hindutva forces in Telangana: The Eatala Phenomenon
Saturday, 19 June 2021
  Prof K. Laxminarayana The official channel of Telangana Rashtra Samithi (TRS) on 30th April aired the news of alleged encroachment upon assigned lands by Eatala Rajender's family for their... Read More...
Life of Bahujans in Brahminical Schools
Friday, 18 June 2021
  Pranav Jeevan P Schools are one of the primary places where the functioning of caste is passed on to the next generation. Savarna kids are indoctrinated of their superiority and Bahujan kids... Read More...
Documenting Bahujan Musical Instruments
Wednesday, 16 June 2021
Dr. Chandraiah Gopani The book under review entitled ‘Mula Dhwani’ (Aboriginal Sound) is edited by Jayadhir Thirumal Rao and Guduru Manoja. This book was released in 2019, both in Telugu and... Read More...
Chaityabhoomi Film Project
Wednesday, 16 June 2021
Somnath Waghmare Dear all, I am plannning to edit our Chaityabhoomi film project this month. We plan to complete the edit by mid-July. After that, I want to organize film screenings online and with... Read More...

Recent Popular Articles

Why did Dr Ambedkar choose Buddhism?
Thursday, 07 January 2021
Kamna Sagar To answer this question, in this article I will expound on B. R. Ambedkar's (1891-1956) early life including his adolescence and schooling, social and political exercises, reasons behind... Read More...
Cancel Culture and Saviour Syndrome
Monday, 11 January 2021
  Anand Silodia A few days ago, Richa Chadha shared the poster of her new movie, ‘Madam Chief Minister’, and it was immediately criticized for the depiction of the dalit protagonist. The... Read More...
Myth of Brahmin Merit: Refutation of Superiority
Sunday, 21 March 2021
  Pranav Jeevan P We have been hearing arguments that try to justify the superiority and monopoly of Brahmins and savarnas in the fields of education and governance based on genetics. Their... Read More...
Election of Kamala Harris: Is America half a century behind South Asia?
Monday, 25 January 2021
  Prof Vivek Kumar On January 20, 2021, Kamala Harris created a history of sorts by taking oath as America's first female Vice President. She is the first woman of South Asian and Afro-American... Read More...
Why so Serious Men?
Friday, 08 January 2021
  Ankit Ramteke Oh, it is a movie about caste issues, progress, and all that. How nice! Do you know the talented Siddiqui is playing an assertive but cunning Tamil Dalit? Wow, As a caste-less,... Read More...